A meta analytical investigation of the relationship between corporate social and financial performance abstract the growing number of academic studies on the impact of corporate social performance csp on corporate financial performance cfp and the mixed findings they report. Orlitzky, marc 1998 a metaanalysis of the relationship between corporate social performance and firm financial performance, dissertation thesis. Corporate financial performance and corporate social. However, there exist two major limitations in the current studies on. Metaanalysis provides one approach to information summary that quantifies a comparison of results from diverse studies which are not directly comparable in terms of research technology or model specification.
A metaanalysis of results from 320 published studies relates environmental, strategic and organizational factors to financial performance. All the aforementioned facts in the research of the relationship between corporate social and financial performance contribute to our interest in analyzing the research problem formulated as follows. This paper aims to empirically explore the interrelationship between cg, csr, financial performance fp and corporate social performance csp using a sample of 297 electronics companies operating in taiwan, a newly industrialized asian economy. Pdf most theorizing on the relationship between corporate social environmental performance csp and corporate financial performance.
Besides econometric modeling, researchers have also conducted metaanalyses based on existing studies. This study examines this question by integrating three meta analyses of more than two decades of research on 1 csp and ffp, 2 firm size and csp, and 3. However, based on the overall analysis, it may be reasonable to come to conclusion that. Causality between corporate social performance and financial performance. Using a reliable source of data on corporate social performance csp, this study explores and tests the relationship between csp. Academic literature on esg and financial performance leechin institute page 1 method a literature search of the academic literature was conducted on proquest, using the terms corporate social performance, financial performance and social responsibility, and financial performance and corporate responsibility.
Jun 18, 2015 the results of the current meta analysis show that a higher representation of females on corporate boards is neither related to a decrease, nor to an increase in firm financial performance, confirming findings from a similar meta analysis on this topic. Corporate social and financial performance journalists. Hard data on financial performance fp of the companies. Between social and financial performance the relationship between social and. Does corporate social responsibility lead to superior. Institutional situations, environmental problems and social responsibility movements have changed significantly over the past four. Corporate governance, corporate social responsibility and. Does environmental performance affect financial performance. Moderating effects time of corporate reputation data collection. Corporate social performance csp is found to be positively associated with prior financial performance, supporting the theory that slack resource.
A secondorder meta analysis timo busch1 and gunnar friede1,2 1university of hamburg, school of business, economics and social science, hamburg, germany 2deutsche asset management investment, frankfurt am main, germany abstract. Besides econometric modeling, researchers have also conducted meta analyses based on existing studies. The impact of corporate social responsibilities on. The impact of corporate social responsibilities on financial. Exploring the relationship between corporate social. We find that female board representation is positively related to. Two models of the determinants of companies environmental investment are estimated in order to capture the difference between. Issues in social and environmental accounting, 2 1, 104. Fur 7 thermore, 8 stated that the interest in corporate social responsibility also stems from the fact that corporate social responsibility builds strong employee bonds with corporations and achieves better employee and organizational performance. This study examines this question by integrating three metaanalyses of more than two decades of research on 1 csp. The benefits of social responsibility cited earlier e.
Metaanalysis of the relation between corporate social performance. This paper summarizes a metaanalysis of statistical results in the literature on industry, firm and business financial performance. Evidence from corporate social responsibility volume 53 issue 5 fred bereskin, seong k. Corporate social performance, corporate financial performance for firms that restate earnings. Rynes abstract most theorizing on the relationship between corporate socialenvironmental performance csp and corporate. Jun 21, 2011 for thirtyfive years, researchers have been investigating the empirical link between corporate social performance csp and corporate financial performance cfp. Rynes abstract most theorizing on the relationship between corporate social environmental performance csp and corporate. Corporate social responsibility and financial performance from a theoretical perspective, stakeholder theory mcguire et al. A metaanalytical investigation of the relationship between corporate social and financial performance abstract the growing number of academic studies on the impact of corporate social performance csp on corporate financial performance cfp and the mixed findings they report. The effect of cultural similarity on mergers and acquisitions. Using a reliable source of data on corporate social performance csp, this study explores and tests the relationship between csp and corporate financial performance cfp. Corporate financial performance and corporate social performance. A metaanalytical investigation of the relationship between corporate social and financial performance abstract the growing number of academic studies on the impact of corporate social performance csp on corporate financial performance cfp and. A metaanalysis of results from 320 published studies relates environmental, strategic, and organizational factors to financial performance.
May 19, 2009 a 2003 study in organization studies, corporate social and financial performance. A metaanalytical investigation of the relationship between corporate social and financial performance. In their metaanalysis of the literature, orlitzky, schmidt, and rynes 2003 further emphasized that reputation may be an important mediating variable of the relationship between corporate social responsibility and financial performance. Meta analysis provides one approach to information summary that quantifies a comparison of results from diverse studies which are not directly comparable in terms of research technology or model specification. Does firm size comfound the relationship between corporate. Hard data on financial performance fp of the companies were obtained from secondary. To reconcile the conflicting results, we statistically combine the results from 140 studies and examine whether these results vary by firms legalregulatory and sociocultural contexts. Corporate social responsibility and financial performance. The robustness of the corporate social and financial performance relation. The results of the current metaanalysis show that a higher representation of females on corporate boards is neither related to a decrease, nor to an increase in firm financial performance, confirming findings from a similar metaanalysis on this topic. A metaanalytical investigation of the relationship between.
Organization studies, volume 24, number 3, pages 403441. There has been some theoretical and empirical debate that the positive relationship between corporate social performance csp and firm financial performance ffp is spurious and in fact caused by a third factor, namely large firm size. These results do not support the business case for diversity, which suggests that diversity. Does corporate social responsibility csr lead to superior corporate financial performance cfp. This study examines whether corporate social responsibility csr towards primary stakeholders influences the financial and the non financial performance nfp of indian firms. Previous research has analyzed and debated corporate governance cg and corporate social responsibility csr independently. Academic literature on esg and financial performance. The relationship between corporate sustainability performance csp and corporate financial performance cfp has long been debated. Orlitzky m, schmidt fl, rynes sl 2003 corporate social and financial performance. Secondary data has been collected for 28 indian commercial banks. Despite a large body of literature examining the relationship between women on boards and firm financial performance, the evidence is mixed. Related literature in management further challenged friedmans view. A meta analysis of the relationship between corporate social and financial performance.
Perceptual data on csr and nfp were collected from 150 seniorlevel indian managers including ceos through questionnaire survey. This paper aims to empirically explore the interrelationship between cg, csr, financial performance fp and corporate social performance csp using a sample of 297 electronics companies operating in taiwan, a newly industrialized. While the findings of this meta analysis were inconclusive, all fifteen studies did provide a correlation between csr and corporate financial results. This study attempts to examine the relationship between corporate social responsibility and financial performance in the indian context. Anecdotal evidence points toward a positive relationship between the two. Ullman 1985 pointed out that the conflicting results could be influenced by many factors, such as sample size, industrial context, inconsistent measurement of csp and cfp, research methodologies, and procedures for data collection and analysis. This study investigates the relationship between corporate social performance csp and corporate financial performance cfp within the context of a particular csp element. A metaanalysis article pdf available in organization studies 243 march 2003 with,195 reads how we measure reads. A metaanalysis, looked at 52 studies on a range of industries and activities, and overall found a positive association between corporate responsibility and financial performance. A 2003 study in organization studies, corporate social and financial performance. A meta analysis of results from 320 published studies relates environmental, strategic, and organizational factors to financial performance.
Methodological development and the theoretical contribution of empirical studies r. The relationship between corporate social responsibility csr and corporate financial performance cfp has long been a central and contentious debate in the literature. Metaanalysis of the relation between corporate social performance and corporate financial performance. The relationship between corporate social and financial. The robustness of the corporate social and financial. The search for a relation between environmental, social, and governance esg criteria and corporate financial performance cfp can be traced back to the beginning of the 1970s. While the findings of this metaanalysis were inconclusive, all fifteen studies did provide a correlation between csr and corporate financial results. Mcwilliams a, siegel d 2001 corporate social responsibility.
Does corporate social responsibility influence firm. Most theorizing on the relationship between corporate socialenvironmental performance csp and corporate financial performance cfp assumes that the. A metaanalytical investigation of the relationship. This paper summarizes a meta analysis of statistical results in the literature on industry, firm and business financial performance. Despite scads research on the relationship between corporate social responsibility and financial performance, literature is still inconclusive. Using a greatly improved source of data on corporate social performance, this paper reports the results of a rigorous study of the empirical linkages between financial and social performance. For thirtyfive years, researchers have been investigating the empirical link between corporate social performance csp and corporate financial performance cfp. They measured csr performance with zakat2 and found there is a strong positive impact of csr on financial performance, including return on equity 0.
The robustness of the corporate social and financial performance. For many decades, there has been a debate about the relation between corporate socialenvironmental performance csp and corporate financial performance cfp. Findings from the most frequently studied relationships include. Corporate social responsibility and firm financial performance. Ullman 1985 pointed out that the conflicting results could be influenced by many factors, such as sample size, industrial context, inconsistent measurement of csp and cfp, research methodologies, and procedures for data collection. The early literature, in the spirit of shareholder theory e.
191 872 1300 18 1512 118 145 522 1084 1005 1392 624 134 460 1562 1149 1602 1140 591 1287 258 1008 564 1359 364 1395 342 456 988 834 485 45 1027 1142 1561 764 397 1075 1488 598 706 476 389 1431 73 1493 882 642 45